On the phone to my mom the other day, she mentioned throwing money at debt. I joked that I don’t like to throw money at debt. Then it just flutters ineffectually to the ground. Instead, I prefer to put my money on or against debt.
We laughed and moved on to another subject, but it got me thinking about the lingo of debt reduction.
Lately, I have avoided saying that we’ll throw money at debt. Something about the phrase just irks me. Strange, really, since I used to say it all the time.
I tried to figure out why, and my mind immediately jumped to “throwing money” at a problem. It’s what people do when they want to remain uninvolved and blameless – when they just want the problem to go away.
With that kind of connotation, no wonder I don’t like the phrase anymore!
My brain being how it is, though, it didn’t just stop at my own linguistic quirks. I started thinking about how other people describe debt and their debt reduction efforts. All around the PF blogosphere, you will find stories of debt that has been (or is being) conquered. People seem to think of it as a beast to be beaten, a dragon to be slain. Inherent in that kind of description is a challenge, motivating us into action.
But is that really the best way to talk about debt?
I’m tempted to say it’s once again about responsibility. In just about any culture’s lore, beasts, monsters and dragons happen to people. The creatures are essentially inflicted on innocent, blameless villagers.
Meanwhile, most of the people with debt had an active role in its creation. So isn’t it a tad revisionist to picture yourself as a white knight? Or, at least, as an underdog still brave enough to face the beast?
Then again, the image of charging forward, crusading for safety… Well, that’s a pretty powerful motivator. It might be what keeps people going in periods of would-be frugal burnout.
So are we using these images to absolve ourselves of the blame? Or is it just to keep us going?
I wonder if the same result could be achieved by picturing it as a mountain to climb. Though I suppose that’s still got the “conquer” attitude toward it.
There’s another problem, too: While you climb a mountain, it stays intact. At least a monster can be slain. Mountains only erode over millennia – and that’s hardly inspiring.
Personally, I’m not very imaginative in this area. Whenever I picture debt, it’s basically an amorphous blob. It casts a very large, very depressing shadow over us. As a whole, the thing feels very menacing – as though it would swallow us up given half the chance.
So, as we make payments, the cloud shrinks and seems to recede. The shadows aren’t quite as dark. And we get a little closer to the sunshine that lies just outside the pall cast by our debt.
I need to know what you guys think. Does the image matter, so long as it spurs you forward? How do you picture/talk about your debt?
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.







{ 1 trackback }
{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }
Great post! The way we talk about things does have a great impact on how we think about them, and vice versa, so I do believe we should carefully consider such things.
Personally, I don't anthropomorphize my debt as some definitely do. I don't give it a name or think of it like a monster coming to eat me. Instead, I see it simply as an obligation — one that I put upon myself, but one that I am responsible to fulfill.
I think, perhaps, that's one reason why I disagree with the notion of "walking away" from debt. That almost makes sense if your debt is something that you're trying to outrun or hide from because it seems impossible to kill. If you could run away from a monster, why not, right? But, in my case, the honorable thing to do when you've made a commitment to someone is to fulfill it and, because I'm not running (even metaphorically), I can be patient. Of course, I still want it gone as soon as possible, but the same can be said of many obligations.
[Reply]
Abigail Reply:
April 14th, 2010 at 6:25 pm
Excellent point, Meg!
For the most part, my debt stays numbers on a screen. (An Excel spreadsheet, actually, because I'm just THAT geeky. But I certainly find myself feeling as though the debt is hovering over us as I described in the post. And that makes it harder to function.
Maybe if we all just tried to keep to numbers, we'd do better.
[Reply]
Abigail Reply:
April 14th, 2010 at 6:25 pm
Excellent point, Meg!
For the most part, my debt stays numbers on a screen. (An Excel spreadsheet, actually, because I'm just THAT geeky. But I certainly find myself feeling as though the debt is hovering over us as I described in the post. And that makes it harder to function.
Maybe if we all just tried to keep to numbers, we'd do better.
[Reply]
I calling it plugging money into the debt hole because it's a hole in my budget that I've (or well, family) dug. And when I use up any savings, I have to replenish the pot of savings like it's stone soup.
I was playing with timelines to map out my goals because Excel is wonderful but I just don't have a good enough grasp of how to work it for all my visual needs.
[Reply]